On December 7, 2017, William Edward Atchison shot and killed two folks then himself at Aztec High School in Aztec, New Mexico. After the taking pictures, The Daily Beast found that Atchison had an lively life on-line, posting on varied alt-right and extremist web sites resembling The Daily Stormer.

He additionally cherished video video games. We know this as a result of, based on The Daily Beast’s reporting, he was an lively person on Valve’s well-liked digital storefront Steam, the place he reviewed 77 video video games. Motherboard independently confirmed this Steam account belongs to Atchison by way of each an acquaintance and data of his on-line exercise on Pastebin. Some of his Steam evaluations are easy—“extraordinarily boring,” he mentioned of Borderlands 2. Other evaluations reveal his hateful ideology as plainly as his posts to The Daily Stormer.

“It was revolutionary for [its] time,” he wrote of the Nazi-killing first individual shooter Wolfenstein 3D again in 2015. “The downside i’ve with it’s the truth that you spend all the sport killing germans – killing white folks.” The assessment then goes on to defend Adolf Hitler and Nazi Germany’s systematic extermination of Jews.

Atchison’s profile is an instance of a bigger downside that Valve—the corporate that owns and operates Steam—would not need to speak about. Steam, which in 2015 Valve mentioned had 125 million lively customers, is stuffed with hate teams, and Valve is doing little to cease them from spreading their hateful messages, together with express requires violence in opposition to minorities.

Read extra: The Alt-Right Thinks ‘Wolfenstein: The New Colossus’ Is Racist to White People

When we first discovered it, Steam had already banned Atchison’s assessment of Wolfenstein 3D, which implies it could not be modified nevertheless it was viewable. Users could not see it in the event that they regarded on the sport’s web page, however might nonetheless see the assessment on Atchison’s profile, and we have been capable of work together with it. At the underside of the assessment, Steam customers might give a thumbs up, thumbs down, or a smiley face—indicating whether or not the person discovered the assessment useful, unhelpful, or humorous. On Atchison’s two banned evaluations, we might nonetheless say they have been humorous, however not whether or not we discovered them useful.

An picture Atchison saved and uploaded to Steam. We’ve eliminated a signature from this picture, which misattributed it to the flawed artist. Image: Steam screengrab

In addition to Atchison’s “banned” evaluations, Steam has additionally left up his screenshots and uploaded paintings, which is a list of extremist views. On Steam, customers can publish each unique paintings and screenshots of their in-game actions. Atchinson did each typically since 2011, and his screenshots have been largely photos of swastikas, anti-Semitic propaganda, and different assorted far proper imagery.

On Monday, we reached out to Valve to ask if it deliberate on eradicating Atchison’s account and posts, which have been all nonetheless up on the time. We didn’t hear again, however it seems that Valve eliminated Atchison’s most important profile web page just a few hours after we emailed the corporate. The majority of his racist photographs and writings have been nonetheless on the positioning till Wednesday morning, when Valve appeared to have wiped his presence from the platform nearly totally. At the time of publication, we might solely discover one in all his photographs on Steam: A screenshot from the sport Garry’s Mod that was organized to appear to be the lynching of a black man, on which Atchison commented with the n-word.

Again, a lot of Atchison’s posts have been on Steam for years.

Atchison’s Steam footprint is an element of a bigger sample. As detailed in The Daily Beast story, he posted about Columbine and different college shooters throughout the online, extolled the worth of Nazi ideology, and typed out veiled threats in opposition to the federal government.

That Valve did not take away the racist rantings of a faculty shooter from its platform for years isn’t a surprise given the corporate’s hands-off strategy to moderating Steam. As we reported in October, Steam’s group pages are stuffed with explicitly racist, homophobic, and in any other case hateful teams.

Valve did not reply to Motherboard’s request for remark for that article both, nevertheless it did take away the precise teams we highlighted after publication. However, there are nonetheless many racist teams on Steam. One straightforward strategy to discover them is to easily use the time period “Nazi” when looking for Steam teams, which on the time of this writing returned 7,930 outcomes.

Some of those teams publicly name for violence in opposition to minorities. For instance, the “about” web page for a Steam group titled “Nazi’s 2.0,” which was shaped in October 3 and has 23 members, says its members need to kill Jews, black folks, transgender folks, and different minorities.

Internet firms have responded in quite a lot of methods since white nationalists reentered the general public consciousness throughout the 2016 US presidential elections. In August, Cloudflare, a significant web safety agency, took the unconventional step of denying its companies to the Nazi website The Daily Stormer, successfully kicking it off the web. Even Twitter, which has lengthy been criticized for permitting Nazis to do as they please on its platform, nominally took steps on Monday to ban accounts related to hate teams.

But these teams are nonetheless on Steam, and it isn’t clear what Valve plans to do about it, if it plans to do something in any respect.

When Motherboard revealed its story about hate teams on Steam in October, many readers responded by saying we have been exaggerating the issue. Many of the self-titled Nazi Steam teams, these readers argued, have been simply kidding.

As we have argued earlier than, hateful messages masquerading as “only a meme” are nonetheless hateful messages. More importantly, as Atchison’s case exhibits, a few of these customers are useless critical, and Valve is permitting them on its platform.

This article sources data from Motherboard